Want to be a guest on Honest Christian Conversations? Send Ana Murby a message on PodMatch
March 12, 2025

What's Wrong With The Chosen?

What's Wrong With The Chosen?

In today's fast-paced culture, many Christians are caught between faith and contemporary spiritual practices that have recently gained popularity. Podcasters aim to explore these intersections, heavily focusing on trends like the Enneagram and The Chosen and writings like “Jesus Calling” and “The Shack.” Listeners must understand that these seemingly innocuous practices/sources of entertainment can harbor more profound, troubling implications as they navigate their faith journey.

I start the discussion with the notion of a "Christian Ouija board," which sounds intrinsically contradictory. A product marketed as a way to consult the divine without associating with traditional spiritualism prompts a deeper look into what it suggests about our spiritual mindset. In exploring this concept, I express concern over how consumers are willing to engage with ideas that inherently conflict with their spiritual beliefs when packaged diversely. The implication that one could interact with the Holy Spirit through interactions mimicking pagan practices sends shivers down the spine of discerning Christians. Listeners are encouraged to critically evaluate their engagement with products and media that may dilute core beliefs.

Then comes a critical examination of popular books such as "Jesus Calling" and "The Shack." Contrary to their warm tones, they lead listeners to wonder whether they might convey a distorted view of Scripture. Using quotes from Doreen Virtue and others familiar with these texts, it becomes apparent that the messages often twist scriptural truths, affecting the theological understanding of readers. Believers must discern their theology from Scripture rather than the interpretations of authors. Faith should reflect the teachings of the Bible, not cater to emotional responses that could mislead readers about their necessity for repentance and salvation.

Following this, the discourse transitions to the controversial practice of Reiki, emphasizing its roots in New Age philosophy. Those who practice Reiki rely on energy healing—a concept alien to biblical texts. Through the discussion, I call listeners to reflect on the importance of grounding their understanding and practices in the truth of Scripture rather than in mystical philosophies that entertain spiritualities detached from Christ.

Shifting focus, practitioners of the Enneagram personality framework become the next subject of scrutiny. Often hailed as a valuable tool for personal growth, our host argues that its origins connect back to esoteric teachings, making it suspect. I suggest that relying on man-made frameworks for identity instead of seeking one's worth in Christ can lead to disillusionment and distract from genuine spiritual growth.

The discussion also touches upon the Myers-Briggs Personality Test and its controversial ties to occultists, paving the way for listeners to recognize the spiritual warfare lurking behind seemingly innocuous personality assessments. This critical examination of various personality tools and spiritual trends invites believers to think more deeply about where they derive their identity and strength from.

Finally, the "Chosen" series is critically examined. While it has garnered considerable popularity for its fresh portrayal of biblical narratives, it has drawn scrutiny, particularly regarding its appropriation of the Gospel’s narrative elements. I poignantly raise the idea that dramatization can replace biblical truth, encouraging listeners to position their reliance on Scripture over any media portrayal—even one that captivates the heart.

FINAL THOUGHTS

Through stimulating analysis and passionate discussion, the episode serves as a vital reminder for all believers to hold fast to scriptural wisdom as they navigate contemporary influences and techniques in their spiritual walks. Grounding identity and truth in Christ is paramount against evolving spiritual trends that demand thoughtful engagement rather than passive acceptance.